Stacked cubes with blue upward arrows form a pyramid below a red and white bullseye with an arrow in the center. Text on the image reads “Goal Setting That Sticks,” “Goals That Matter,” and “The Thrive With Intention Show.”

Goal Setting That Sticks Part 4: Goals That Matter | Ep. 13

Here we are in mid-January, and I want to ask you something, honestly. Have your resolutions already started to quietly fall apart?

If they have, this doesn’t mean you lack discipline or follow-through. More often than not, it means the goals themselves were never aligned.

Goal setting that sticks isn’t about pushing harder or trying to become a different version of yourself. It’s about choosing goals that actually fit who you are and the season you’re in right now.

That’s what we’re focusing on in Part 4 of this series. In case you missed part one…START HERE.

Listen, watch, or read all about it below 👇


🎙 Listen or Watch the Episode

In Part 4 of the Goal Setting That Sticks series, we take everything we’ve already done and turn it into goals that actually matter. Not goals you should want. Not goals that look good on paper. But goals you can realistically live with all year long.

This episode is where identity meets action and where clarity turns into momentum.

Listen to the Podcast

Watch on YouTube

Key Takeaways

  • Why identity-based goals create more follow-through than outcome-only goals
  • How to set goals that align with who you’re becoming, not who you used to be
  • What “SMART with SOUL” goals are and why they work better
  • How milestones help goals feel supportive instead of overwhelming
  • Why alignment, not pressure, is the secret to goal setting that sticks

Helpful Links

It isn’t just your hormones that are changing.


📰 Read the Full Blog Post

If you want goal setting that sticks, you have to stop starting with the goal.

I know that sounds counterintuitive, but stay with me. Most of us jump straight into what we want to do without ever slowing down to think about who we want to be. And when that happens, even the best intentions eventually fall apart.

This work starts with identity.

It doesn’t mean you failed. It just means those goals were never aligned.

jody phifer | the thrive with intention show

Identity-Based Goals Are the Foundation

Before we talk timelines or outcomes, we start with identity-based goals. These are high-level goals that give you direction without boxing you in.

They’re not tactical yet. They don’t include numbers or deadlines. They answer one simple question:

If I focused on just one thing in this area of my life, what would make the biggest difference?

For me, one of my big five areas is body. My identity-based goal there is to build strength and consistency. Not perfection. Not chasing a specific number. Just strength and consistency that feels realistic in midlife.

Another area is home. My goal isn’t a perfectly styled house. It’s creating a spacious, clutter-free environment that actually supports how I want to live.

This is where goal setting that sticks really begins. When your goals reflect how you want to live, not just what you want to accomplish.

Why SMART Goals Need a Soul

You’ve probably heard of SMART goals. Specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound. And yes, those are helpful.

But they leave out something important. You.

That’s why I teach SMART with SOUL goals. The SOUL part brings alignment back into the process. It asks why this goal matters now, how it connects to your identity, and how you’ll know you’re actually practicing it instead of just thinking about it.

Inside the free Goal Setting Planner, I walk you through these questions step by step because this part matters. This is where goals stop feeling forced and start feeling supportive.

✨Your next chapter starts here—take the quiz.


Milestones Make Goals Livable

Once your identity-based goals and SMART with SOUL goals are clear, the next step is setting milestones. This is where clarity turns into momentum.

For each of your big five areas, you choose three to five milestones. Not everything you could do. Just the few things that will actually move the needle over time.

For example, if money is one of your big five and your focus is awareness and impulse control, your milestones might look like tracking spending weekly, reviewing accounts monthly, and setting one aligned spending boundary.

Milestones create structure without pressure. And that’s a big reason this kind of goal setting actually sticks.

Accountability Can Be Gentle

One of my personal growth goals this year is to read a personal growth book every month. I know myself well enough to know that accountability matters, so I built it into the goal.

That’s exactly how the Better With Every Book Club came to life. It’s a simple, low-pressure way to stay engaged and supported.

We read one book per month, and I share key takeaways, reflections, and practical ways to apply what we’re learning through a private podcast and community.

Our first book is Build the Life You Want by Arthur Brooks and Oprah Winfrey, and it’s a beautiful complement to this whole process.

Learn more or join the book club here.

When You Want Deeper Support

As you move through this work, you might realize you want more clarity, deeper guidance, or someone to walk alongside you as you navigate your next chapter.

That’s exactly what we do inside Shift & Thrive, my one-on-one coaching experience. This is where we personalize the process, work through identity shifts and mindset blocks, and create momentum that actually fits your life. You can learn more about Shift & Thrive here.

Remember, goal setting that sticks isn’t about doing more. It’s about choosing what actually matters and letting that guide your energy, your time, and your choices.

Next, we’ll move into Part 5 and create your 90-day blueprint. But for now, let yourself slow down. Let your brain think. And give this work the space it deserves.


About the Author

Hi, I’m Jody Phifer, a Certified Midlife Coach for Women and founder of Thrive With Intention™. I help women thrive through menopause and the midlife transitions nobody warned us about.

Whether you’re navigating changing hormones, an empty nest, shifting relationships, questions about your purpose, or simply don’t feel like yourself anymore, you’ll find honest conversations, practical tools, and coaching to help you confidently decide what comes next.

When I’m not coaching or recording the podcast, you’ll probably find me with a cup of coffee, spending time with my husband and son, or planning my next mountain adventure.

👉Not sure where to start? Take the free Shift Happens™ Quiz or join the Thrive Tribe for practical encouragement and resources for navigating menopause and midlife.

Similar Posts