Sparkly purple and silver background with bold text that reads "Goal Setting That Sticks" and cursive text below saying "The Anti-Resolution Approach." At the bottom, the image includes the logo for "The Thrive With Intention Show."

Goal Setting That Sticks Part 2: The Anti-Resolution Approach | Ep. 11

This is part two of my Goal Setting That Sticks series, and it’s all about ditching resolutions and choosing something far more powerful instead. Here’s part one in case you missed it.

If you’ve ever made New Year’s resolutions with the best intentions… and then quietly dropped them by February, you’re not alone.

Traditional resolutions don’t fail because of laziness or motivation. They fail because they’re built on the wrong foundation.

In this episode, I’m sharing a different way to approach goal setting.

One that actually supports who you’re becoming. Listen, watch, or read all about it below 👇


🎙 Listen or Watch the Episode

In part two of this six-part series, I explain why New Year’s resolutions don’t work and what to do instead. Rather than starting with outcomes or to-do lists, we begin with identity.

You’ll learn how choosing a theme for the year, rooted in future-you work, creates alignment, clarity, and follow-through that lasts all year long.

🎧 Listen to the Podcast

📺 Watch on YouTube

https://youtu.be/1Y2A9PXd-DM

✨ Key Takeaways

  • Resolutions fail because they focus on outcomes, not identity
  • Lasting change happens when who you’re becoming leads the way
  • A yearly theme acts as a North Star for decisions and energy
  • Future-you work makes follow-through feel more natural
  • The right theme should feel aligned, meaningful, and slightly stretching

🔗 Helpful Links


It isn’t just your hormones that are changing.


📰 Read the Full Blog Post

Why New Year’s Resolutions Don’t Work

Let’s be honest. We all know New Year’s resolutions don’t work. We’ve made them. We’ve broken them. Usually more than once.

Every January, we promise ourselves things like “I’m going to work out more” or “I’m going to get organized” or “This is the year I finally get it together.” And then real life shows up. Motivation fades. And by mid-February, most of those resolutions are gone.

That doesn’t mean you don’t want change badly enough. It means the system you’ve been using isn’t designed to support real, lasting change.


The Real Problem With Traditional Goal Setting

Here’s the truth most people don’t talk about. Resolutions are usually made quickly, under pressure, and without much thought about the life we actually want.

They’re often based on what we think we should want, what everyone else is doing, or what we’ve tried before. And almost always, they skip the most important piece. Identity.

We focus on outcomes without changing who we are or who we’re becoming. And when identity doesn’t shift, behavior doesn’t stick.

We don’t change through willpower. We change when our identity changes.

jody phifer | the thrive with intention show

The Anti-Resolution Approach: Start With Identity

That’s why this year, we’re doing something different.

Instead of starting with resolutions, we start with a theme for the year.

A theme isn’t a to-do list. It’s not rigid or controlling. It’s something grounded and supportive. A word, phrase, or sentence that becomes your North Star. Something you can come back to when you’re tired, overwhelmed, or unsure which decision to make.

Your theme helps you zoom out and reconnect with who you want to be in this next season of your life.


Why Identity Drives Lasting Change

This is where future-you work comes in. And yes, it’s exactly what it sounds like.

You intentionally connect with the version of you who is already living the life you want. You notice how she carries herself, what matters to her, what she no longer tolerates, and how she treats her time, energy, and body.

There’s a lot of research behind this. Our brains are constantly predicting the future and making decisions based on who we believe ourselves to be. We don’t change through willpower. We change when identity changes.

James Clear talks about this in Atomic Habits when he says that lasting change doesn’t come from setting better goals. It comes from becoming a different kind of person. When your self-image shifts, your behaviors naturally follow.

That’s why people can win the lottery and end up broke again. Or lose a significant amount of weight and gain it back. When identity stays the same, behavior eventually follows it right back.


How Future-You Work Makes Follow-Through Easier

One of my favorite books on this topic is Be Your Future Self Now. It explains how powerful it is to mentally and emotionally connect with the version of you who is already living the life you want.

When you emotionally connect with future you, things shift. You stop trying to force change and start becoming the woman who naturally makes different choices.

Inside the free goal-setting planner that goes along with this series, there’s a guided future-you visualization. It’s one of the most powerful tools I use with my coaching clients, and it consistently creates clarity.

Patterns emerge. You realize what you want more of and what you’re finally ready to release. And from that place, following through feels more natural, not forced.


Choosing a Theme That Actually Supports You

From that grounded place, choosing your theme becomes clear. It doesn’t just sound good. It feels right.

Some of my past themes have been Massive Action and Do It Anyway. Each one met me exactly where I was and helped guide my decisions throughout the year.

This year, my theme is Be the Blueprint. And I feel it in my bones.

Your theme should feel aligned and meaningful, and just a little bit scary. Not overwhelming. Not paralyzing. But stretching. Like it’s calling you forward.


✨Your next chapter starts here—take the quiz.


How to Use Your Theme All Year Long

Once you choose your theme, don’t tuck it away.

Put it everywhere. On your phone lock screen. On your bathroom mirror. In your planner. Let it guide your decisions, your boundaries, and your energy all year long.

This isn’t about perfection. It’s about intention.

And if you haven’t listened to Episode 10 yet, make sure you go back and start there. This process is designed to be done in order, and each step builds on the last.

You don’t need another resolution. You need alignment. And this is how you create it.


About the Author

Hi, I’m Jody Phifer, a Certified Midlife Coach for Women and founder of Thrive With Intention™. I help women thrive through menopause and the midlife transitions nobody warned us about.

Whether you’re navigating changing hormones, an empty nest, shifting relationships, questions about your purpose, or simply don’t feel like yourself anymore, you’ll find honest conversations, practical tools, and coaching to help you confidently decide what comes next.

When I’m not coaching or recording the podcast, you’ll probably find me with a cup of coffee, spending time with my husband and son, or planning my next mountain adventure.

👉Not sure where to start? Take the free Shift Happens™ Quiz or join the Thrive Tribe for practical encouragement and resources for navigating menopause and midlife.

Similar Posts